|Member of the Federal Reserve Board of Governors|
February 24, 2006 – March 31, 2011
|President||George W. Bush|
Kevin Maxwell Warsh
April 13, 1970
Albany, New York U.S.
|Education||Stanford University (A.B.)|
Harvard University (JD)
Kevin Maxwell Warsh (born April 13, 1970), is an American academic, financier, and former government official. During and in the aftermath of the 2008 financial crisis, Warsh was a governor of the Federal Reserve System, and acted as the central bank's primary liaison to Wall Street and served as the Federal Reserve's representative to the Group of Twenty (G-20) and as the Board's emissary to the emerging and advanced economies in Asia. Prior, Warsh served as Special Assistant to the President for Economic Policy and Executive Secretary of the White House National Economic Council. He is the Shepard Family Distinguished Visiting Fellow in Economics at Stanford University's Hoover Institution, a scholar and lecturer at the Stanford Graduate School of Business, a member of the Group of Thirty, a member of the Panel of Economic Advisers of the Congressional Budget Office, and a former steering committee member of the Bilderberg Group. He has conducted research in the field of economics and finance, and has advised several private and public companies.
Warsh was born in Albany, New York, and grew up nearby, attending Shaker High School in Latham. He received an A.B. in public policy from Stanford University in 1992 with a concentration in economics and political science. He then attended Harvard Law School and graduated cum laude with a J.D. in 1995. He also took coursework in market economics and debt capital markets at MIT Sloan School of Management and Harvard Business School.
In the November 2010 Federal Open Market Committee meeting, Warsh remarked about his hometown: "Also, President Dudley mentioned that he visited upstate New York, where I'm from, and he noted that the economy there appeared to be 'hunkered down.' That's not a nearterm phenomenon—it's been going on for about 40 years. [Laughter] He also noted that the economy there was at a tipping point, and that is true, but the only way it ever tips is over."
From 2002 to 2006, Warsh was Special Assistant to the President for Economic Policy, and Executive Secretary of the National Economic Council. His primary areas of responsibility included domestic finance, banking and securities regulatory policy, and consumer protection He advised the President and senior administration officials on issues related to the U.S. economy, particularly fund flows in the capital markets, securities, banking, and insurance issues. Warsh participated in the President's Working Group on Financial Markets and served as the administration's chief liaison to the independent financial regulatory agencies.
Federal Reserve Board
President Bush nominated Warsh and Randall Kroszner to fill two Fed vacancies on January 27, 2006. Warsh's nomination drew some criticism, based on his age and inexperience. At 35 years old, Warsh was the youngest appointment in the history of the Federal Reserve. At the time, former Fed vice chairman and Reagan appointee Preston Martin said Warsh's nomination was "not a good idea" and that if he had a voice in the Senate, he would vote no. Ben Bernanke wrote "His youth generated some criticism, including from former Board vice chairman Preston Martin, but Kevin's political and markets savvy and many contacts on Wall Street would prove to be invaluable.":124 In his confirmation documents, Warsh listed two published writings - "Deciding to Run for Congress: An Opportunity Cost Model with Partisan Implications" and "Corporate Spinoffs and Mass Tort Liability."
At his confirmation hearing on February 14, 2006, Warsh touted his experience on Wall Street: "I hope that my prior experience on Wall Street, particularly my nearly 7 years at Morgan Stanley, would prove beneficial to the deliberations and communications of the Federal Reserve."
His first meeting of the Federal Open Market Committee (FOMC), the Fed's policymaking body, was in March 2006. In March 2007 - less than a year before the rescue of Bear Stearns - Governor Warsh suggested that financial innovation made the system safer:
"First, liquidity is significantly higher than it would otherwise be due to the proliferation of financial products and innovation by financial providers. This extraordinary growth itself is made possible by remarkable improvements in risk-management techniques. Hewing to my proposed definition, we could equally state that financial innovation has been made possible by high levels of confidence in the strength and integrity of our financial infrastructure, markets and laws. Moreover, remarkable competition among commercial banks, securities firms and other credit intermediaries have helped expand access to—and lower the all-in-cost of—credit. Interest rate risk and credit risk exposures are now more diversified.
Look no further than dramatic growth of the derivatives markets. In just the past four years, notional amounts outstanding of interest rate swaps and options tripled, and outstanding credit default swaps surged more than ten-fold. These products allow investors to hedge and unwind positions easily without having to transact in cash markets, expanding the participant pool.
Syndication and securitization also lead to greater risk distribution. Commercial and industrial (C&I) lending potential has expanded with the adoption of syndication practices, allowing credit risks to be spread across a greater number of participating banks and non-bank lenders. Perhaps an even more significant support for the expansion of C&I loans is the rapid growth of collateralized loan obligations (CLOs)-special purpose entities that buy C&I loans with funds raised from investors seeking different risk exposures. CLOs allow loans to be financed primarily with high-rated debt securities issued to institutions like mutual funds, pension funds, and insurance companies. Indeed, in recent years, the share of syndicated C&I term loans funded by institutional investors is estimated to have exceed that funded by commercial banks."
Warsh played a significant role in navigating the financial market turmoil of 2007 and 2008. According to author David Wessel, "Warsh established himself as the chairman's protector in Republican circles and Bernanke's bridge to Wall Street chief executives." Bernanke would write "Don Kohn, my vice chairman, with his long experience at the Fed, and Kevin Warsh, with his many Wall Street and political contacts and his knowledge of practical finance, were my most frequent companions on the endless conference calls through which we shaped our crisis-fighting strategy.":172
During the crisis Warsh tried to engineer mergers between Citigroup and Goldman Sachs and Wachovia and Goldman Sachs. These efforts failed. On September 20, 2008 he was granted a waiver to deal with his former employer Morgan Stanley. The next day Morgan Stanley was converted into a bank holding company in order to access Federal Reserve loans, in effect saving the firm. According to the Wall Street Journal, "Timothy Geithner, president of the Federal Reserve Bank of New York, and Kevin Warsh, a Fed governor and former Morgan Stanley executive, worked in New York to sort out the details with Goldman and Morgan Stanley." The editors summarized the decision-making, "Mr. Warsh was part of former Fed Chairman Ben Bernanke’s inner circle during the worst of the panic. Having worked at Morgan Stanley, he provided crucial insight into the real condition of Wall Street, and well before the panic he told his Fed colleagues that the financial system was vastly undercapitalized. 'I think, most fundamentally, that the business model of investment banks has been threatened, and I suspect the existing business model will not endure through this period,' Mr. Warsh told a Fed meeting on March 18, 2008."
Warsh was tasked by Bernanke to help devise a financial reform program to mitigate the risks of future trouble. Bernanke wrote “In late 2008, amid the crisis firefighting, we at the Fed began working on our own proposals for financial reform. I wanted to have a well formulated position before the legislative debates went into high gear. Kevin Warsh led a committee of Board members and Reserve Bank presidents that laid out some key principles. Kevin’s committee considered a more explicitly 'macroprudential' or system-wide, approach to supervision and regulation. Historically, financial oversight had been almost entirely 'microprudential' – focused on the safety and soundness of individual firms, on the theory that if you take care of the trees, the forest will take care of itself. In contrast, the macroprudential approach strives for a forest-and-trees perspective.”:437
Throughout 2008 Warsh predicted that inflation would rise despite financial turbulence and economic weakness:
- March 2008: "On the inflation front, there is little reason to be confident that inflation will decline. There are reasons to believe that our inflation problems will become more pronounced and, I fear, more persistent."
- June 2008: "Inflation risks, in my view, continue to predominate as the greater risk to the economy."
- September 2008: "I'm still not ready to relinquish my concerns on the inflation front."
Many economists and observers, including conservatives, have argued that this focus on inflation and failure to recognize the risk of deflation significantly exacerbated the crisis. In his memoir, Chairman Bernanke writes about his frustration, "I vented in an email the next day to Don Kohn: 'I find myself conciliating holders of the unreasonable opinion that we should be tightening even as the economy and financial system are in a precarious position and inflation/commodity pressures appear to be easing.'"
Warsh's principle concern about the permanent use of QE were highlighted in a panel discussion later alongside Bernanke. Warsh stated "My overriding concern about continued QE, then and now, involves the misallocations of capital in the economy and the misallocation of responsibility in our government. Misallocations seldom operate under their own name. They choose other names to hide behind. They tend to linger for years in plain sight. Until they emerge with force at the most inauspicious of times and do unexpected harm to the economy."
In September 2009, with unemployment at 9.5% and climbing, Warsh argued that the Fed should begin to pull back on its efforts to help the real economy recover: "if policymakers insist on waiting until the level of real activity has plainly and substantially returned to normal — and the economy has returned to self-sustaining trend growth — they will almost certainly have waited too long… There is a risk, of much debated magnitude, that the unusually high level of reserves, along with substantial liquid assets of the banking system, could fuel an unanticipated, excessive surge in lending." The runaway inflation he warned about never appeared. University of Oregon Professor Tim Duy wrote in response to the speech that it looked as though "monetary policymakers are more willing to use unconventional monetary policy to support Wall Street than Main Street."
At the November 2010 FOMC meeting, Warsh was extremely skeptical of the Fed's plan to generate economic activity and jobs by trying to lower long-term interest rates. Although unemployment was close to 10%, Warsh told his colleagues that he would only vote for QE2 out of respect for Chairman Bernanke: "If I were in your chair, I would not be leading the Committee in this direction, and frankly, if I were in the chair of most people around this room, I would dissent." Even if unemployment were "unacceptably high," he suggested that he would vote against the program continuing if inflation inched up a bit: "if inflation were to move up and were to be broadly consistent with the implicit inflation target [2%] in different people's minds around this room, even if unemployment were unacceptably high, I think that would be time to stop this program. If inflation expectations were to move out of the range that they have been in for a long time, that would be a reason to end this program, even if unemployment were exceptionally high and GDP were well below what we think the economy is ultimately capable of." The Federal Reserve has a legal dual mandate to pursue maximum employment as well as to ensure price stability.
He elaborated on his opposition to the program: "I think we are removing much of the burden from those that could actually help reach these objectives, particular the growth and employment objectives, and we are putting that onus strangely on ourselves rather than letting it rest where it should lie. We are too accepting of dangerous policies from others that have been long in the making, and we should put the burden on them." While Federal Reserve officials routinely offer their views on non-monetary questions such as taxes, spending and regulations, it is unusual for a Federal Reserve official to suggest that monetary support should be withheld in order to compel other branches of government to enact the Federal Reserve's favored policies.
Warsh worried about the efficacy of continuing extraordinary monetary policy accommodation. Bernanke would write of Warsh's views in the debate over QE2, "Kevin Warsh had substantial reservations. He was one of my closest advisers and confidants, and his help, especially during the height of the crisis in the fall of 2008, had been invaluable. He had supported the first round of securities purchases, begun in the midst of the crisis. Now that financial markets were functioning more normally, he believed that monetary policy was reaching its limits, that additional purchases could pose risks to inflation and financial stability, and that it was time for others in Washington to take on some of the policy burden. . . . As he had promised, Kevin voted in favor but, the following week he delivered a speech in New York and published an op-ed in the Wall Street Journal that reflected his reservations. He argued that monetary policy alone could not solve the economy’s problems, and he called for tax and regulatory reforms aimed at increasing productivity and longer-term growth. I agreed that other Washington policymakers should take more responsibility for promoting economic growth. Federal spending on infrastructure projects such as road buildings, for example, could have helped make our economy more productive in the longer term while putting people back to work right away. Yet nobody expected anything to happen on the fiscal front or in other areas that Kevin highlighted, either. The reality was that the Fed was the only game in town. It was up to us to do what we could, imperfect as our tools might be. . . . I never questioned Kevin’s loyalty or sincerity. He had always participated candidly and constructively, as a team player, in our deliberations. And I was grateful that he had voted for the second round of asset purchases despite his unease. I saw his public comments more as an indictment of policymakers outside the Fed than as an attack on the Feb policies. Kevin would leave the Board three months later, but not because of any policy disagreement. We had agreed when he was appointed in 2006 that he would stay for about five years. We remain close to this day.”:489
Warsh announced his intent to resign from the Board in a letter sent to President Obama on February 10, 2011, effective around or on March 31, 2011. When he left the Fed, CNBC's Larry Kudlow expressed disappointment and described Warsh as a "hard money hawk."
In 2002, Warsh married Jane Lauder, a granddaughter and heiress of Estée Lauder and long-time employee of the family business, the Estée Lauder company. The couple lives in Manhattan. Formerly general manager of Origins, Lauder has served as the Global Brand President for Clinique since 2014. According to Forbes, her net worth as of September 27, 2017 was $2 billion. Warsh's father in law is Ronald Lauder.
- "Members of the Board of Governors: Kevin M. Warsh". The Federal Reserve Board. Archived from the original on March 10, 2006. Retrieved January 5, 2016.
- Hearst Newspapers (March 29, 2006). "New Fed governor is just 35". The Baltimore Sun. Retrieved January 6, 2016.
- "Kevin Warsh". Hoover Institution. Retrieved May 2, 2018.
- Chan, Sewell (February 10, 2011). "Kevin Warsh to Resign From Fed's Board of Governors". The New York Times. Retrieved January 5, 2016.
- "Kevin Warsh". Stanford Graduate School of Business. Retrieved July 25, 2019.
- "Panel of Economic Advisers | Congressional Budget Office". www.cbo.gov. Retrieved July 25, 2019.
- "Former Steering Committee Members". Bilderberg Group. Archived from the original on February 2, 2014. Retrieved February 8, 2014.
- Gemperlein, Joyce (November 2007). "November/December 2007 Spotlight: Kevin M. Warsh, '92 The Governor Is In". Stanford Magazine. Retrieved January 5, 2016.
- "November 2-3 2010 FOMC meeting" (PDF).
- "Another suspect Bushie". New Republic. Retrieved September 27, 2017.
- Lublin, Joann S.; Hilsenrath, Jon (January 8, 2009). "Fed Moves Closer to Picking Geithner's Successor". The Wall Street Journal. Retrieved January 5, 2016.
- Lattman, Peter (February 16, 2006). "Kevin Warsh Has Got It Going On". The Wall Street Journal - Law Blog. Retrieved January 5, 2016.
- Benjamin, Matthew; Murray, Brendan (February 13, 2006). "Questions are raised on Bush pick for Fed". International Herald Tribune. Marketplace by Bloomberg. Retrieved January 6, 2016.(subscription required)
- Bernanke, Ben (2015). The Courage to Act: A Memoir of a Crisis and Its Aftermath. W. W. Norton & Company. ISBN 9780393353990.
- "Kevin Warsh 2006 confirmation document" (PDF).
- "February 14 2006 Warsh confirmation hearing" (PDF).
- "Bush Names 2 to Fill Fed Board Seats". The New York Times. The Associated Press. January 28, 2006. Retrieved January 6, 2016.
- "Senate OKs Fed, economic adviser nominations". NBC News. The Associated Press. February 17, 2006. Retrieved January 6, 2016.
- "March 2006 FOMC meeting" (PDF).
- "March 2007 Kevin Warsh speech".
- Ip, Greg (October 31, 2007). "Bernanke, in First Crisis, Rewrites Fed Playbook". The Wall Street Journal. Retrieved January 6, 2016.
- Ip, Greg (May 30, 2008). "Fed's Fireman On Wall Street Feels Some Heat". The Wall Street Journal. Retrieved January 6, 2016.
- Wessel, David (August 3, 2010). In FED We Trust: Ben Bernanke's War on the Great Panic (Reprint ed.). New York: Crown Business. ISBN 9780307459695.
- Sorkin, Andrew Ross (September 7, 2010). Too Big to Fail: The Inside Story of How Wall Street and Washington Fought to Save the Financial System--and Themselves (Updated ed.). Penguin Books. ASIN B003XQEVUI.
- "Warsh Morgan Stanley Waiver 9/20/2008" (PDF).
- "Morgan Stanley Granted Federal Bank Holding Company Status By U.S. Federal Reserve Board of Governors". Morgan Stanley. Retrieved September 27, 2017.
- "Goldman, Morgan Scrap Wall Street Model, Become Banks in Bid to Ride Out Crisis" (PDF).
- Board, The Editorial. "Trump and the Fed". WSJ. Retrieved September 6, 2019.
- "Meeting of the Federal Open Market Committee on March 18, 2008" (PDF). Federal Reserve. September 6, 2019. Retrieved September 6, 2019.
- "March 2008 FOMC meeting" (PDF).
- "June 2008 FOMC meeting" (PDF).
- "September 2008 FOMC meeting" (PDF).
- "Cause for Depression". National Review. Retrieved September 27, 2017.
- Bernanke, Ben S. (October 5, 2015). The Courage to Act: A Memoir of a Crisis and Its Aftermath (1 ed.). W. W. Norton & Company. ASIN B00TIZFP0I.
- Warsh, Kevin (June 7, 2018). "Lessons Learned from 10 Years of Quantitative Easing: The Knowledge Problem" (PDF). Hoover Institution. Retrieved July 31, 2019.
- "Warsh September 2009 speech".
- "Tim Duy 2009 response to Warsh speech".
- "Wall Street Journal op-ed November 8 2010".
- "Kevin M. Warsh - Resignation" (PDF). Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve. February 10, 2011. Retrieved January 6, 2016.
- Censky, Annalyn (February 10, 2011). "Fed official Kevin Warsh resigns". CNN Money. Retrieved January 6, 2016.
- Kudlow, Larry (February 12, 2011). "2 hard money hawks leaving the central bank scene: US #KevinWarsh, and German #AxelWeber. With commodities soaring, QE3 from #Bernank? No!". @larry_kudlow. Retrieved September 27, 2017.
- Luther, Justin (July 26, 2012). "UPS Board Names Economic Expert Kevin Warsh A Director". United Parcel Service. Retrieved January 6, 2016.
- Bryan, Bob (December 2, 2016). "Trump is forming an economic advisory team with the CEOs of Disney, General Motors, JPMorgan, and more". Business Insider. Retrieved June 1, 2017.
- Toy, Vivian S. (May 20, 2010). "Jane Lauder Apartment for Sale". The New York Times. Retrieved January 5, 2016.
- Trower, Alexandra; D'Andrea, Dennis (June 3, 2008). "Jane Lauder Named Senior Vice President, General Manager of Origins, The Estee Lauder Companies Inc". Reuters. Retrieved January 6, 2016.
- "The Estée Lauder Companies Names Jane Lauder Global Brand President, Clinique". EL Companies. Retrieved June 1, 2017.
- "Jane Lauder". Forbes. Retrieved September 27, 2017.
- "40 under 40: 20. Kevin Warsh". Fortune. 2009. Retrieved January 6, 2016.
- Warsh, Kevin, and Jeb Bush. "Commentary: A New Strategy for Economic Growth." The Wall Street Journal. August 10, 2011.
- Warsh, Kevin. "Commentary: The 'Financial Repression' Trap." The Wall Street Journal. December 6, 2011.
- Warsh, Kevin, and Stanley Druckenmiller. "Commentary: The Asset-Rich, Income-Poor Economy." The Wall Street Journal. June 19, 2014.
- Wessel, David. In Fed We Trust: Ben Bernanke's War on the Great Panic. New York: Crown Business, 2009. ISBN 978-0-307-45970-1 OCLC 464303608 "Chapter 6: The Four Musketeers: Bernanke's Brain Trust." pp. 106–115.