Reform Party of the United States of America
|Chairperson||Bill C. Merrell|
|Headquarters||Bohemia, New York|
|Membership (February 2016)||5,294|
|Seats in the Senate|
0 / 100
|Seats in the House|
0 / 435
0 / 50
|State Upper House Seats|
0 / 1,921
|State Lower House Seats|
0 / 5,411
|Other elected offices||9 (2019)|
Perot, who received 18.9 percent of the popular vote as an independent candidate in the 1992 presidential election and wanted to participate also in the 1996 presidential election, thought Americans were disillusioned with the state of politics as being corrupt and unable to deal with vital issues. Perot claimed to represent a viable alternative to Republicans and Democrats, and, as a result, founded the Reform Party. Perot won 8.4 percent of the popular vote in 1996. Although he did not receive a single electoral vote, no other third-party or independent candidate has since managed to receive as high a share of the vote.
The party has nominated several notable candidates over the years, including Perot himself, Pat Buchanan, and Ralph Nader. Its most significant victory came when Jesse Ventura was elected Governor of Minnesota in 1998, although he left the party shortly into his term. Donald Trump was a member of the Reform Party during his 2000 presidential campaign. In around the year 2000, party infighting and scandals led to a major decline in the party's strength. Beginning with Buchanan's poor showing in the 2000 election, no Reform Party presidential candidate has ever been able to attain at least 1 percent of the vote.
- 1 The Ross Perot movement
- 2 Foundation and rise of the party
- 3 Apex: 1996 presidential election
- 4 Plateau and decline
- 5 Collapse
- 6 Presidential tickets
- 7 Platform
- 8 Active state affiliates
- 9 See also
- 10 References
- 11 External links
The Ross Perot movement
Ross Perot's 1992 presidential election campaign
The party grew out of Ross Perot's efforts in the 1992 presidential election, where—running as an independent—he became the first non-major party candidate since 1912 to have been considered viable enough to win the presidency. Perot received attention for focusing on fiscal issues such as the federal deficit and national debt; government reform issues such as term limits, campaign finance reform, and lobbying reform; and issues on trade. A large part of his following was grounded in the belief he was addressing vital problems largely ignored by the two major parties.
A Gallup poll showed Perot with a slim lead, but on July 19 he suspended his campaign, accusing Republican operatives of threatening to sabotage his daughter's wedding. He was accused by Newsweek of being a "quitter" in a well-publicized cover-page article. After resuming his campaign on October 1, Perot was dogged by the "quitter" moniker and other allegations concerning his character. On Election Day many voters were confused as to whether Perot was actually still a candidate. He ended up receiving about 18.9 percent of the popular vote, a record level of popularity not seen in an independent candidacy since former President Theodore Roosevelt ran on the "Bull Moose" Progressive Party ticket in 1912. He continued being politically involved after the election, turning his campaign organization (United We Stand America) into a lobbying group. One of his primary goals was the defeat of the North American Free Trade Agreement during this period.
Foundation and rise of the party
In 1995, Republicans took control of the House of Representatives, largely on the strength of the "Contract with America", which recognized and promised to deal with many of the issues Perot's voters had mobilized to support in 1992. However, two of the major provisions (Constitutional amendments for term limits and the balanced budgets) failed to secure the two-thirds congressional majorities required to be submitted to the states.
Dissatisfied, the grassroots organizations that had made Perot's 1992 candidacy possible began to band together to found a third party intended to rival the Republicans and Democrats. For legal reasons, the party ended up being called the "Reform Party" ("Independent Party" was preferred, but already taken, as were several variants on the name). A drive to get the party on the ballot in all fifty states succeeded, although it ended with lawsuits in some regions over state ballot access requirements. In a few areas, minor parties became incorporated as state party organizations.
Apex: 1996 presidential election
At first, when the 1996 election season arrived, Perot held off from entering the contest for the Reform Party's presidential nomination, calling for others to try for the ticket. The only person who announced such an intention was Dick Lamm, former Governor of Colorado. After the Federal Election Commission indicated only Perot and not Lamm would be able to secure federal matching funds—because his 1992 campaign was as an independent—Perot entered the race. Some were upset that Perot changed his mind, because in their view, Perot overshadowed Lamm's run for the party nomination. This built up to the beginning of a splinter within the movement, when it was alleged certain problems in the primary process—such as many Lamm supporters not receiving ballots, and some primary voters receiving multiple ballots—were Perot's doing. The Reform Party claimed these problems stemmed from the petition process for getting the Reform Party on the ballot in all of the states, since the party claimed they used the names and addresses of petition signers as the basis of who received ballots. Primary ballots were sent by mail to designated voters. Eventually, Perot was nominated and he chose economist Pat Choate as his vice-presidential candidate.
Exclusion from the debates
Between 1992 and 1996, the Commission on Presidential Debates changed its rules regarding how candidates could qualify to participate in the presidential debates. As Perot had previously done very well in debates, it was a decisive blow to the campaign when the Commission ruled that he could not participate on the basis of somewhat vague criteria — such as that a candidate was required to have already been endorsed by "a substantial number of major news organizations," with "substantial" being a number to be decided by the Commission on a case-by-case basis. Perot could not have qualified for the debates in 1992 under these rules, and was able to show that various famous U.S. presidents would likewise have been excluded from modern debate by the Commission on Presidential Debates.
Despite legal action by the Perot team, and an 80 percent majority of Americans supporting his participation in the debates, the Commission refused to budge and Perot was reduced to making his points heard via a series of half-hour "commercials". In the end, Perot and Choate won 8 percent of the vote.
Plateau and decline
By October 1997, factional disputes began to emerge with the departure of a group that believed Perot had rigged the 1996 party primary to defeat Lamm. These individuals eventually established the "American Reform Party" (ARP). The ARP is actually a minor political action committee. Then chairman, Roy Downing, said the split came about when it was "...discovered [that the Reform Party] was a top down party instead of a bottoms up organization." Although members of the group attempted to persuade former Colorado Governor Dick Lamm – Perot's chief rival for the nomination – to run for president as an Independent, he declined, pointing out that he had promised before running that he would not challenge the party's decision. During this time, Perot himself chose to concentrate on lobbying efforts through United We Stand America.
American Reform Party
When the ARP was founded, Jackie Salit noted in the Christian Science Monitor: "At its founding meeting in Kansas City in 1997, the 40 black delegates in the room, led by the country’s foremost African-American independent – Lenora Fulani – represented the first time in US history that African-Americans were present at the founding of a major national political party."
The ARP has yet to organize in more than a few states. In the 2000, 2004, and 2008 elections, the American Reform Party supported Ralph Nader for president. The ARP is not a political party in the conventional sense. It does not have ballot access in any state, and it does not run candidates. It supports third party candidates and independents who support the primary principals of the Party's platform.
About 2010–2011, the party shifted from a relatively centrist platform to a Tea Party-style economic liberal and fiscal conservative one. In the 2012 presidential election, the ARP endorsed Republican Party nominee Mitt Romney against incumbent president Barack Obama. In the 2016 presidential election, the Party endorsed the Republican candidate Donald Trump.
- In New York State, the Integrity Party is an ARP affiliate. The group, led by Darren Johnson, used the state's fusion election system in cross-endorsing a Democratic sheriff candidate, Vincent Demarco, in Suffolk County, helping him narrowly win election. The party had also run a host of other candidates and attempted to go statewide in 2006, fielding Phoebe Legere as a candidate in the 2006 New York gubernatorial election. Legere and the party did not qualify for the November ballot.
- The Reform Party of Northern Mariana Islands is an affiliate of the ARP.
Mid-term elections of 1998
In 1998, the Reform Party received a boost when Jesse Ventura was elected Governor of Minnesota. According to the League of Women Voters, the Reform Party USA obtained more votes nationwide in 1998 than did any other third party in America (without those garnered by Ventura). Counting Ventura's performance, Reformers took in more votes than all other third parties in the United States combined, establishing the Reform Party as America's third largest party.
2000 presidential election
The Reform Party's presidential candidate for the 2000 election was due federal matching funds of $12.5 million, based on Perot's 8 percent showing in 1996. Early on, there was a failed effort to draft Ron Paul.
Donald Trump entered the race briefly, giving television interviews outlining his platform. Trump was progressive on social issues, and supported allowing openly gay soldiers in the military, saying: "it would not disturb me". Trump considered himself a conservative, but criticized Pat Buchanan, saying: "I'm on the conservative side, but Buchanan is Attila the Hun." He withdrew from the race citing the party's infighting, as did Jesse Ventura and the Minnesota Reform Party. Donald Trump stated: "So the Reform Party now includes a Klansman, Mr. Duke, a neo-Nazi, Mr. Buchanan, and a communist, Ms. Fulani. This is not company I wish to keep." "Mr. Duke" was a reference to David Duke, a former leader of the Ku Klux Klan.
Pat Buchanan decided to leave the Republican Party because: "The Republican Party at the national level has ceased to be my party. This divorce began around the end of the Cold War when President (George) Bush declared it to be a New World-order party and began intervening all over the world. While he and I were allies and friends during the Cold War, I just felt that once the Cold War was over the United States should return to a more traditional non-intervention foreign policy."
After a bitter fight, Pat Buchanan secured the Reform Party nomination over John Hagelin of the Natural Law Party. Hagelin and an anti-Buchanan faction walked out and held a separate convention across the street, where they nominated Hagelin as the party's candidate. The dispute went to the courts and the FEC decided that Buchanan was the legitimate nominee and awarded him $12.6 million in campaign funds. Buchanan's running mate was Ezola B. Foster. Buchanan got 449,225 votes, 0.4 percent of those voting,[clarification needed] and the party lost its matching funds for 2004.
2004 presidential election
By the October 2003 National Convention, the Reform Party had only begun rebuilding, but several former state organizations had elected to rejoin now that the interference from the Freedom Parties was gone. They increased their ranks from 24 to 30 states, and managed to retrieve ballot access for seven of them. (Buchanan's poor showing in 2000 had lost ballot access for almost the entire party.)
Because of organizational and financial problems in the party, it opted to support the independent campaign of Ralph Nader as the best option for an independent of any stripe that year. While the endorsement generated publicity for Nader and the Reform Party, the party was only able to provide Nader with seven ballot lines down from the 49 of 51 guaranteed ballot lines the party had going into the 2000 election.
Activities of the party in 2005
In 2005, a dispute arose: the number of National Committee members required under the party's by-laws to call meetings of the National Committee, and the Executive Committee did so. These members came from several states including Texas, Michigan, and Florida. At both meetings, it was determined that a national convention would be called and held in Tampa, Florida. The Chairman at the time and National Committee members from Arizona, California, and Oklahoma boycotted the National and Executive Committee meetings, claiming the meetings were illegitimate. As a result, those states held a second convention in Yuma, Arizona.
In response to a suit filed by the group that met in Tampa, leaders of the Reform Party filed a Racketeer Influenced and Corrupt Organizations Act (RICO) complaint claiming the Tampa group were extremists and guilty of conspiracy.
In 2006, the Reform Party nominated candidates in Arizona, and petitioned to regain ballot access in several other states where state Reform Party organizations were active. The Reform Party of Kansas nominated a slate of candidates, led by Iraq War veteran Richard Ranzau. In Colorado's 4th congressional district, "fiscal conservative" Eric Eidsness (a former assistant U.S. Environmental Protection Agency administrator and Navy veteran) ran on the Reform Party ticket. He received 11.28 percent of the vote, five times the winning candidate's margin of victory; he later switched his affiliation to the Democratic Party. The Florida Reform Party granted use of its ballot line for governor to Max Linn of Florida Citizens for Term Limits (a Republican-leaning organization) in the 2006 gubernatorial election. Linn retained professional campaign staff with connections to the Perot and Ventura campaigns, but received only 1.9 percent of the vote. As of March 2007, the Reform Party had ballot access for the 2008 presidential election in four states (Florida, Kansas, Louisiana, Mississippi) and had already started petitioning in an additional four.
2008 National Convention
At the national convention, Ted Weill of Mississippi was nominated to be the party's 2008 presidential candidate. Frank McEnulty of California, the 2008 presidential candidate of the New American Independent Party, was nominated to be the party's 2008 vice-presidential candidate. David Collison of Texas was elected national chairman of the party. However, the party could not announce the results of the national convention on its web site until October because of a court order obtained by a dissident faction associated with the Independence Party of New York. Therefore, the Weill/McEnulty ticket appeared on the ballot only in Mississippi, in which it received 481 votes.
An erroneous news report was broadcast by ABC News that stated the party had endorsed John McCain. Frank MacKay of the dissident Independence Party of New York faction had made the endorsement, not the Reform Party USA. Reform Party USA Reference David Collison, the Reform Party's chairman, said during a 2009 interview, "Do you believe that any legitimate national party would endorse the Republican candidate for President rather than have a candidate of their own?"
The candidates for the nomination included:
- Alan Keyes, a former diplomat and Republican candidate
- Frank McEnulty who eventually became the vice presidential nominee
- Ted Weill, an activist from Mississippi who eventually became the presidential nominee
- Daniel Imperato, who later joined the Libertarian Party
- Gene Chapman, a blogger from Denton, Texas
2009 legal action
A long-standing feud in the party involved John Blare, of the Reform Party of California, and the Reform Party officers.
On December 4, 2009, a New York Federal judge heard MacKay v Crews on the question of who are the legal Reform Party officers. On December 16, 2009 the judge ruled in favor of David Collison's faction.
Collison said: "After over two years of litigation in Texas and New York, it is my profound pleasure to announce that US District Court Judge Joseph Bianco of the Eastern District of New York has ruled in our favor, and has further reinforced the 2008 ruling of Judge Carl Ginsberg of the 193rd District Court in Texas."
In January 2010, Central Intelligence Agency operations officer Charles S. Faddis announced his support of the party in The Baltimore Sun: "I have decided to throw in my lot with the Reform Party of the United States." Faddis later left the party, and ran in 2016 for Maryland's 5th congressional district as a Republican.
In February 2010, former Reform Party Chairman Pat Choate emerged to discuss the appeal of the Tea Party movement, contrasting it with Ross Perot's party, saying: "The difference with the Tea Party is it's been heavily pushed by a bunch of talk-show conservatives. You have the Republican Party attempting to use this as a means to pull independents or conservative independents to their policies, to their agenda."
In February, Congressional candidates filed to run as Reform Party candidates in all four of Mississippi's congressional districts, but none for any statewide offices. Among these were Barbara Dale Washer, Tracella Lou O'Hara Hill, and Anna Jewel Revies.
In April 2010, former U.S. Vice President Dan Quayle condemned the Reform Party on CBS, saying: "Many remember the Reform Party of the 1990s, which formed around the candidacy of Ross Perot. I sure do, because it eliminated any chance that President George H.W. Bush and I would prevail over Bill Clinton and Al Gore in 1992. Speaking on behalf of the Bush-Quayle campaign, to this day we firmly believe that Perot cost the Republican Party the White House."
Pat Choate in an April 28, 2010 interview with Monmouth University's student newspaper remained suspicious of the Tea Party movement, saying: "At these [Tea Party] events, a professional Republican always speaks. What to me is questionable is that the Tea Parties endorse candidates, but never endorse Democrats—they seem to be a front for the Republican Party. We were seen as very serious. Perot gave millions, we fielded candidates, and we were a real threat to the status quo. The media treats the Tea Parties as a sign of dissatisfaction, and views them skeptically."
Kristin M. Davis, the Manhattan madam involved in the Eliot Spitzer scandal, announced on June 27, 2010 that she was running for governor on an independent line in New York State using the name, Reform Party without Reform Party authorization after failing to secure the Libertarian Party nomination. Davis condemned the Democrats and Republicans for catering to wealthy white males, saying: "Where are the women, the Hispanics, the African-Americans and the gay people? We must reject their tired old thinking...."
On June 29, 2010, Reform Party National Committee chairman David Collison sent Davis a cease-and-desist notice demanding that she immediately change the name under which she was seeking to run for governor. Davis made no attempt to obtain permission to run as an official Reform Party candidate, and therefore withdrew her use of the Reform Party name. Davis was not a member of the Reform Party. Davis changed her Independent Ballot Line name and filed as an independent candidate by obtaining the required signatures needed in New York State to run for governor on the "Anti-Prohibition" line.
2012 presidential election
At the national convention, the Reform Party nominated Andre Barnett from New York for president and Ken Cross from Arkansas for vice president. Among those who sought the nomination before dropping out several months prior to the convention were former Savannah State University football coach Robby Wells, economist Laurence Kotlikoff, historian Darcy Richardson, and former Louisiana Governor Buddy Roemer.
2016 presidential election
|Year||Presidential nominee||Home state||Previous positions||Vice presidential nominee||Home state||Previous positions||Votes||Notes|
Candidate for President of the United States
|Pat Choate||District of Columbia||Economist||8,085,294 (8.4%)
|Virginia||White House Director of Communications
Candidate for President of the United States
Candidate for California's 48th State Assembly district
Candidate for President of the United States
|California||Candidate for Mayor of Berkeley
Candidate for President of the United States
Candidate for Governor of California
|Mississippi||Nominee for United States Senator from Mississippi
|Frank McEnulty||California||Businessman||481 (<0.1%)
|2012||Andre Barnett||New York||Entrepreneur||Ken Cross||Arkansas||Engineer, businessman||962 (<0.1%)
Rocky De La Fuente
Candidate for Florida's 47th State House of Representatives district
Candidate for Florida's 11th congressional district
The Reform Party platform includes the following:
- Maintaining a balanced budget, ensured by passing a Balanced Budget Amendment and changing budgeting practices, and paying down the federal debt
- Campaign finance reform, including strict limits on campaign contributions and the outlawing of political action committees
- Enforcement of existing immigration laws and opposition to illegal immigration
- Opposition to free trade agreements like the North American Free Trade Agreement and Central America Free Trade Agreement, and a call for withdrawal from the World Trade Organization
- Term limits on U.S. Representatives and Senators
- Direct election of the United States President by popular vote and other election system reforms
- Federal elections held on weekends or Election Day (on a Tuesday) made a national holiday
A noticeable absence from the Reform Party platform has been social issues, including abortion and gay rights. Reform Party representatives had long stated beliefs that their party could bring together people from both sides of these issues, which they consider divisive, to address what they considered to be more vital concerns as expressed in their platform. The idea was to form a large coalition of moderates; that intention was overridden in 2001 by the Buchanan takeover which rewrote the RPUSA Constitution to include platform planks opposed to any form of abortion. The Buchananists, in turn, were overridden by the 2002 Convention which reverted the Constitution to its 1996 version and the party's original stated goals.
Active state affiliates
The party's active state affiliates are:
- Reform Party of Texas
- Reform Party of California
- Reform Party of New Jersey (reorganized in 2010)
- Reform Party of Florida
- Reform Party of North Carolina
- Reform Party of New York
- "New Data: Libertarian Party Registrations Rising". TruthInMedia. Archived from the original on May 3, 2016. Retrieved May 5, 2016.
- Reform Party. "Reform Party National Committee - FAQ".
- "Current Office Holders". Reform Party National Committee.
- "Welcome to the Reform Party National Committee website". Reform Party National Committee.
- Atlantic Herald - Fall of the Reform Party[permanent dead link]
- "Tea party activists: Don't confuse them with independents". CSMonitor.com. February 16, 2010. Retrieved June 13, 2010.
- "American Reform Party Endorses Mitt Romney for President", ARP statement November 2, 2012
- Party, American Reform. "The American Reform Party endorses Donald Trump for President of the United States | American Reform Party". www.americanreformparty.net. Retrieved December 8, 2016.
- "Presidency 2000 - The Reform Party Candidates". Politics1. September 13, 2000. Archived from the original on October 28, 2010. Retrieved June 13, 2010.
- "Independent Gay Forum - Pat Buchanan: On the Record". Indegayforum.org. Archived from the original on June 13, 2010. Retrieved June 13, 2010.
- "Richard Watanabe - Newsweek Quotes, 1999". Sph.umich.edu. Archived from the original on December 21, 2008. Retrieved June 13, 2010.
- "Video: Headlines - Men Behaving Bradley | The Daily Show | Comedy Central". The Daily Show. February 14, 2000. Retrieved June 13, 2010.
- "QUOTATION OF THE DAY". The New York Times. February 14, 2000.
- Kaczynski, Andrew; Massie, Christopher (August 26, 2015). "Top Racists And Neo-Nazis Back Donald Trump". BuzzFeed News.
- "Buchanan Foster - home". Web.archive.org. October 18, 2000. Archived from the original on October 18, 2000. Retrieved June 13, 2010.
- Kim, Eun-Kyung (September 13, 2000). "FEC rules Buchanan due $12.6 million in campaign funds – Reform Party faction also claimed money". The San Diego Union-Tribune. p. A.10.
- "LAWSUIT NEWS, Ballot Access News". Ballot-access.org. Retrieved June 13, 2010.
- "PRESIDENTIAL BALLOT STATUS, Ballot Access News". Web.archive.org. Archived from the original on June 18, 2002. Retrieved June 13, 2010.
- [dead link]
- "Third Party Watch". Third Party Watch. Retrieved June 13, 2010.
- John Eichler (December 13, 2006). "Colorado Cumulative Report". Sos.state.co.us. Archived from the original on December 6, 2006. Retrieved June 13, 2010.
- Campbell, Greg (October 2, 2007). "Eidsness withdraws from 4th District race". Greeley Tribune. Retrieved June 13, 2010.
- "Reform Party of Florida site". Rpfla.org. Retrieved June 13, 2010.
- "Max Linn's website". Maxlinn.com. Retrieved June 13, 2010.
- "BallotAccess.org". BallotAccess.org. Retrieved June 13, 2010.
- "Dallas Reform Party Meeting", www.ballot-access.org, July 7, 2008
- "Archived copy". Archived from the original on September 24, 2008. Retrieved November 17, 2008.CS1 maint: archived copy as title (link)
- http://abcnews.go.com/Politics/wireStory?id=6012839[dead link]
- "Rebuilding the Reform Party | Third Party Voices". Ahherald.com. August 6, 2009. Archived from the original on January 15, 2017. Retrieved June 13, 2010.
- "Conservative President 2008: Imperato Looking For Reform Party Nomination". Conservativepresident2008.blogspot.com. February 15, 2007. Retrieved June 13, 2010.
- "Ballot Access News " Blog Archive " Federal Judge in New York Hears Reform Party Lawsuit". Ballot-access.org. Retrieved June 13, 2010.
- "Ballot Access News " Blog Archive " Federal Court in New York Issues Ruling in Internal Reform Party Dispute". Ballot-access.org. Retrieved June 13, 2010.
- "Corruption : Corruption News and Photos". baltimoresun.com. Retrieved June 13, 2010.
- All Things Considered (February 6, 2010). "Pat Choate, Historian Michael Kazin On Tea Party's Appeal". NPR. Retrieved June 13, 2010.
- "Challengers file in 4 Miss. congressional races - WLBT 3 - Jackson, MS:". Wlbt.com. March 1, 2010. Retrieved June 13, 2010.[permanent dead link]
- "Mississippi 2010 Midterm Election". thegreenpapers.com.
- Finn, Tyler (April 2, 2010). "Finn, Tyler. "Dan Quayle Urges Tea Party Not to 'Go Perot'" ''CBS News'' April 2, 2010". Cbsnews.com. Retrieved June 13, 2010.
- "Reform Party of New Jersey Pat Choate on Tea Parties, Foreign Policy, and NAFTA |". Reformpartynj.org. April 28, 2010. Retrieved June 13, 2010.[dead link]
- "Kristin Davis, New York Gubernatorial Candidate, Will Petition under Reform Party Label". ballot-access.org.
- "Reform Party chooses Andre Barnett for president;". Ballot Access News. August 13, 2012. Retrieved November 9, 2012.
- While Nader and Camejo ran as independents, they also received the nomination of the Reform Party.
- De La Fuente and Steinberg were also the nominees of the American Delta Party.